20 mA at the battery?!? :ironic: Even for a NiMh, that is VERY low, you might want to check that again. After the boost circuit, that would mean the LED itself is only getting maybe five or so mA (wild guess), and would be quite dim. My IU's all pull around 170 mA at the tail, give or take, even with a NiMh. Remember that because of the voltage boost circuit, the LED only sees a fraction of the current, at over 3 volts, of what is being drawn from the battery, at less than 1.5 volts.
The brightness difference with the DS is very noticable side by side with the CS, and I use CO (warmest) color tints, so it is also less blue than the stock. I can line up an original BS light with a later CS, or one of my warmer CS mods, and my latest DS mod, and it is a very nice progression of brightness increase. I think the DS does a bit better job of focusing light to the hotspot, and so has just a bit more throw to it, such as it is in a 5 mm light.
The circuit does not seem to be sensitive to the Vf of the LED used, like the one in a Fenix E0 is, so the runtime and drive current stay about the same after the mod. It is a little overdriven from the start, but the Nichia CS and DS LED's are about the toughest 5 mm's out there, so lifespan should not be a concern. For reference, an Arc AAA drives the Nichia harder. And as I've warned before, in an overdrive applicaton, the GS with it's lifespan rating of 1/10 that of the DS would be the one to manifest lumen maintenance issues first.
But like Gunga said, once you have done this once, it is no big deal, and the LED's don't cost much more than an incan lightbulb, which only lasts about 25 hours, so enjoy! When you do "kill" an LED, unlike a light bulb, it usually won't leave you in the dark, it just gets a bit dimmer over time, and bluer if you really are cooking it. Dorcy 1st and 2nd Gen. 1xAAA lights drive their LED's very hard, and I managed to take one with a JELED mod back down to stock output level after about two years of use. I re-modded it with a Nicha CS, and I doubt I will see the problem again, the Nichia is much more durable.