both the P60 and SR-6 are ~5.5W bulbs, there is no significant difference in power consumption between the 2, - they should have remarkably similar behavior. Any difference between the 2 that is noticeable would be color temperature or beam profile. That is, assuming your SR-6 is not malfunctioning in some way.
A Surefire lumen is a torch lumen measured on partially depleted cells from what I understand. It's almost like an "averaged" output to be expected during the runtime, pretty much all surefire incandescent lights start off brighter on fresh cells than their lumen rating.
LumensFactory tells you at what voltage a particular bulb lumen and other behaviors can be expected. So the SR-6 is 120 bulb lumen at 4.8V, 1.1A. If you take the same bulb and de-rate it for partially discharge cells, and then losses from lens and reflector, it's around around the 65 lumen that surefire rates their P60 at.
Eric