Speaking of chanlk, here's what he said: " There is a small percentage of old style P3s that kill their batteries and if you have one, it will be exchanged for a new P3. The problem is not known to exist in the new style."
That's mistaken; the one I got from them yesterday definitely is not new. It is not the new style, nor did it come with the battery protection tab.
I'm not complaining, mind you. They did send a pair of new batteries in addition to the P3. And, unlike certain other manufacturers, they did not charge a "handling fee".