Sanyo CR123s vs. Amontech Titaniums and Battery Staion 123s?

geepondy

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 15, 2001
Messages
4,898
Location
Massachusetts
I've bought Sanyo CR123's at Botach for 20/$20 plus shipping (never had a problem with Botach on this) but also read here that the Amondotech Titaniums and Battery Station house brands for the same price are pretty good so I'm wondering if either two of the latter are noticeably better then the Sanyo's?
 
I've bought Sanyo CR123's at Botach for 20/$20 plus shipping (never had a problem with Botach on this) but also read here that the Amondotech Titaniums and Battery Station house brands for the same price are pretty good so I'm wondering if either two of the latter are noticeably better then the Sanyo's?

IME, Sanyos are better. and Amondo's are unreliable.
 
Botach also has Energizers. Since I ordered Sanyos over a year ago, I'm ordering the Energizers so I won't have to mark them. The Titaniums are fairly good batteries, but not quite equal to the name brand.

I don't know about the Surefires. Their prices have been going up but I've heard they're pretty good too.
 
Botac probably bought the Energizers and Sanyos for a discount in very large qty as their prices beat anyone elses I've seen. Otherwise, Energizers and Sanyos are typically pricier than Amondotech Titaniums and BS cells. I mention this for a reason: The reason why Titaniums and BS cells are so cheap is acceptance requirements are loosened to improve yield at the factory, so more product per input resources, and less scrap/reject material to eat into profits. What this means for the end customer is that there is more variability in performance and quality. What you pay for in the additional cost of the more well known brands is stricter acceptance requirements and the overhead associated with those requirements, but at the same time, you get a more consistent quality and performing product in the end. Numerous tests have been done on Titanium and BS cells that show larger variation in performance and quality (various charge levels, etc. from same batch, date code, etc.). They're not bad batteries, but they are compromised for the cost. Just bear that in mind in your purchase decision.
 
Top