State of the Art in Cheap Chargers?

Chrontius

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
2,150
Location
Orlando, FL
So, I've heard lots of good things about the Eneloop charger with a model number ending in five, but also that it's only got one 'charging' light. This is acceptable, but probably also avoidable - what do you fine folks recommend for:

4-bay AA/AAA charger
4+ bay AAA/AA/C/D charger

9V is a strong plus, since I grabbed a 9V powered paintball hopper.

This Vanson looks nice, but that's just my buzzword-scanning first impression.
 
What is your definition of cheap? Under $30? Under $40?

In these threads:
http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=70935
http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?p=2181730

The Vanson you noted was king at one time.

SilverFox would probably be the best one to tell which charger is the best bang for the buck within your budget range, once that's known.

The Sanyo NC-MQN05 would be the charger you were referring to in your original post. That is the good Eneloop charger, if you can find it.
 
Hello Chrontius,

When I consider the value of a charger, I don't put price first.

I am more interested in a charger that will take good care of my batteries.

You might want to check out the Maha C808M and the Maha C490F.

Tom
 
The vanson seems to be a reasonable compromise. It's definitely cheap, does all common cell sizes. It can produce excellent charge results if you use it right, and by that I mean, leave the cells on the charger in trickle charge mode (green light) for a few hours after the charge has completed to really finish off the charge. for larger capacity cells, like 10AH Ds, that extra charging time may be like, an extra day...

That leads me to the major pit fall of that charger, which is it's charge rate. it's ideal for AAA and AA cells, in fact, almost perfect, it will detect termination reliably on AAA and AA cells almost 100% of the time. Leave em on for an extra couple hours after termination and you're golden. When dealing with C size cells, it does pretty good, the charging is slow, it seems to detect termination points about 95% of the timer or better. The problem arises on D cells, which in my experience, it will miss the termination about 20% of the time. But with such a slow charge rate, this is not really a huge factor, just be aware of how long they have been on, if It hasn't terminated a D size ~10AH after about 24 hours, then it may have missed the termination. I like to make sure I charge Ds in sets of 4 at a time, that way if 3 finish, and 1 is still going for several hours, I can usually assume it missed termination on that cell and can pull them all and they are done.

It has been a reliable charger overall and I can't complain, for the money it's a great deal.
 
Chrontius - The BC1HU is an excellent, reliable and economical choice. I'm sure you can find a better charger or two on the market but expect to pay 3-5X the price.

mdocod - the BC1HU & BC2HU have a 14hr safety timer so on the large D cells, even if it were to miss the -dV it should still time out after the 14 hours and switch to trickel model.

Tom you interested in doing some 9V charger reviews? :)
http://batteryjunction.com/tpec-ttp9v-4bay.html
http://batteryjunction.com/tpec-ttp9v-8bay.html
 
Top