I have SL BatonLite.
I would say with fresh batts my one is defiantly brighter than a single LED and has a very defuse beam probably due to it having to shine through the smoked G.E. Lexan lens.
[EDIT: Sorry, I should have said much brighter than a single 5mm LED, certainly not brighter than a Luxeon.]
With regards to the switch being unresponsive, I have noticed that the BatonLite really needs to be run on Energizer “N” size (LR1) batts.
Using other brand batteries you might find that there are problems with the button switch although you can still make it work by twisting the tail.
I think this is due to slight variations in the size of different brands.
(Not only do you need to find the N size batteries, you’ve got to get the right brand in order for it to function as it should.)
N size batteries also have rather low capacity compared to AA or even AAA and I have noticed that the Batonlite does get dim soon after putting in fresh batteries.
My BatonLite very rarely comes out on day trips with me since I got my Opalec and now I’ve got my 2aa Inratech and dat2zip BB500 & MadMax I can’t see it’s going to be spending much time in my pockets.
The BatonLight was also my first real LED and I can remember the first night I had it I was constantly shinning it around the house muttering things like “I can’t believe it’s so bright and white”. Now that I’m used to using my BB500 or Madmax whenever I use the BatonLite I convince myself that I can’t see anything with it.
Whether this is just because the BB500 and MadMax are so bright and I’ve just got used to them or whether it’s because they are so bright that I’m happily giving myself permanent eye damage I’m not sure.!!?