surefire m4 vs lx2

[eldopa]

got a quick question.. i know this is an odd one, but here we go. im leaning toward an m4 devastator, but at the same time, i like the lx2. its the state of the art. 200 lumens for 2 hour with 2 cells. what are the advantages of the m4?? throw? better spot? i really want i tight spot that will reach out far. i dont really care about the size//

thanxx . dave

 

[Size15's]

Given you have decided to choose between two very different flashlights; it may help us to offer advice if you explain what you intend to use the flashlight for.

I'm not sure I would usually have to decide which like to select between the two for any given task/use. Either I need the M4 (or more likely M6 in my case), or I just use the LX2 (which I would have with me along with a larger outdoor flashlight such as the M4/M6 anyway)

Al

 

[Patriot]

The M4 isn't typically a light that most people would carry around with them unless they were wearing a fanny pack or on a belt pouch. The LX2 on the other hand would be an ideal EDC light, enhanced by its slim design and great pocketclip. If you prefer to carry a light without drawing attention, the LX2 would be a nice choice.

 

[eldopa]

like i said, i dont care much about the size. is the m4 gonna be a better bet for throwing a spot out far? if its not quite a bit better than the lx2 in that respect, then id just go for the lx2. i have a rail mount for my rifle, so either of the two would be mounted to my rifle when in use. i dont have a lot of lights and dont want to. otherwise id buy both of them. really, the most important thing to me is spot power, and distance the spot can be thrown

dave

 

[dano]

An M4 will out throw most LED based lights, including the LX2, especially under real world conditions (i.e. ambient light, obstructions, etc).

 

[ugrey]

If you want something to hang on your rifle, get a SureFire Scoutlight. It is LED but it also throws very well, but not as far as an M4. An M4 is an awfully large light to hang on a rifle.

 

[Monocrom]

If size doesn't matter, get the M4.

 

[a99raptors]

Incandescents (M4) give a better colour rendition (IMHO) than LEDs, that sometimes make it difficult in getting good depth perception outdoors. Indoors, no problemo in both.

 

[Solscud007]

I say forget the M4 and get a M6. a lot more options and upgrades. Plus it is shorter. only downside is you cant weapon mount it. However you can get one of the weaponlight mounts that accept turbo heads.

 

[Sgt. LED]

like i said, i dont care much about the size.
i have a rail mount for my rifle, so either of the two would be mounted to my rifle when in use. i dont have a lot of lights and dont want to. otherwise id buy both of them. really, the most important thing to me is spot power, and distance the spot can be thrown

Just going from what you said, It's going to be the M4 for you then.
Operating the LX2 while mounted on a riflle could be a huge PITA.

 

[eldopa]

hey guys... thanx for all the info. i just got back from a camping/fishing trip. caught some beautiful rainbows and brook trout. i went to battle creek here in northern california. i caught the brook trout in gurnsey creek
i won the auction on ebay for the M4 devastator. i has the surefire beam cover and lanyard on it as well. got it for $220. they say its brand new. we'll see...

dave

 

[Patriot]

Neither light was designed for weapon mounting and each would have its own problems in that regard.

In any case, the M4 is a nice light and you'll get much enjoyment from it.

Congrats on your purchase.

:thumbsup:

 

[eldopa]

ive got a picatiny mount for the light. i measured the clearance for the bezel, and it will work. ive got a quad rail on my rifle..

 

[Patriot]

Didn't mean to imply that it couldn't be attached, just that the M4 wasn't designed as a weaponlight, per say. It's long and therefore isn't ideal when compared to Surefire's line of dedicated systems which it seems they've limited to 3 cells in series or 6 cells in a 3x3 configuration. Personally speaking, I wouldn't put a 4 cell light on even my largest rifle but if the length works for you, that's all that matters. :)

Paul


P.S. Speaking of long lights, this is good for a chuckle....... http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showpost.php?p=2906139&postcount=130

 

[Size15's]

One of the issues with multi-celled non-WeaponLights is that the batteries can become crushed as a result of weapon recoil.
Changing the complete set of batteries at the first signs of battery crushing is a good idea.
This is less of a concern for light-recoil weapons and/or weapons that are fired/used infrequently.
I assume that before and after use the weapon will be inspected/cleaned. It makes sense to check the batteries at the same time.

SureFire does offer the M98 Millennium Universal WeaponLight although it ain't cheap. This will reduce the likelihood of battery damage and help protect the lamp assembly plus offer a number of other benefits.

Also, the M4 is part of the LeopardLight for [sharp-shooter] rifles so it can take use on a weapon such as a rifle...

 

[eldopa]

thanx for the info. the battery issue was one that i hadnt thought of. the light will probably see very little use mounted.

db

 

[Sean]

The M4 will out throw the LX2 no problem. If that is your only concern then the M4 is what you want.