Nothing I have seen has yet to beat carbon-arc in light output! My buddy works at Musco, and even they (engineering) have nothing that beats it. But I haven't see any operating here in the SFO bay area in many years. Used to be able to see the beam from the 60" lights in the sky from San Fran to San Jose (20 miles). Phenomenal. Made me a light geek on the spot. Some day...I'll own one for fun. Have yet to see the 15-20kw HMI conversion on the 60" in person.
By the way, a good source of parabolic mirrors is to use the glass mirrors used on traffic signals...they come in 2 sizes. Most have bee converted to LED, and some are Alzak aluminum...but diffused. If you can get the "retired" glass ones from your towns corp yard...make an enclosure, install/focus an automotive HID setup, and you've got a nice bright light.
~Michael