Car ownership isn't the only way to give people a better standard of living. This issue here is giving people convenient, inexpensive transportation. A comprehensive system of trolleys, rapid transit, and heavy rail will do so for far less total money than every poor person spending $2500 to buy one of these cars, and without the attendent road carnage we see here in the US. IMHO, any developing country should not emulate the huge mistake we made in the US of abandoning public transit in favor of the auto. This is especially true in countries with very high population density where increased auto ownership will result in congestion, smog, etc. quite quickly. Also, for short trips of less than a few miles, mechanized transit is more a want than a need. We would do well even here in the US to walk or bike such distances.
Honestly, I couldn't possibly disagree with you more. I lived in Flushing for about two decades. Took public transportation most of my Life. Convenient is hardly the best way to describe public transportation where you and I live. Standing in the rain at a bus stop, which is sometimes nothing more than a bus schedule on a pole, is far from fun. But during rush hour, it's not too bad. I had the "fun" of working 3rd Shift (Midnight - 8am). Miss a bus, might as well grab a Snickers bar.... cause you'll be waiting for awhile.
Still, I used to feel sorry for the poor guys who worked 2nd shift. Miss a subway train after 11:30pm, and you can count on waiting about 45 minutes for the next one.
Even those who work the morning shift encounter problems. Mostly overcrowding in the subway cars. Wouldn't be so much of a problem
if some folks would shower! Nothing like being so close to a total stranger that under all other circumstances, that level of "intimacy" would only be reserved for a wife or loving girlfriend.
But the real fun begins when things go wrong. Nearly every time it rains, the subway station at 179th street in Jamaica gets flooded! And it's not the only one. But it sure is great when the token booth clerks have no clue about alternate transportation by bus. And the announcements at the last minute of, "Everyone off. This train is out of service."
Then there's sharing the trains with deranged Homeless folks, lunatics, and I think I already mentioned people who smell. You call that a better standard of living??
I had to put up with that $#^% for about a year and a half at my last job assignment. Towards the end, I started losing it a bit! I got into a shouting match with some piece of $#^% lunatic that sat there and started singing.... off key.... at the top of his lungs.... with his eyes closed! You should have seen him jump in fear when I shouted at him to shut the Hell up! I didn't even care that he was
much bigger and taller than me. I didn't even care if I'd have to get physical with him. People get on the subway in NYC, and they act like Low-life garbage!
Now, I work at a job that I can drive to. I spend half an hour on the highway and side roads, instead of an hour and a half dealing with public transportation. I get to decide if I want to listen to music, instead of some @-hole who feels likes blasting
his music all over the subway car.... While everyone just sits there, pretending it's okay. Well, everyone except me. (Funny, the look on their faces is priceless when someone decides not to put up with their $#^%). I decide who sits next to me, if I want to car pool. No need to worry if some lunatic, Homeless or otherwise, decides to get into the same subway car with me. No need for me to wait at all before starting to head off to work. And if it rains, who cares! With a car,
I'm responsible for getting to work on time. If my car breaks down,
I'm responsible.... Instead of some guy who didn't repair a Bus or Subway train properly because he couldn't possibly care less if I and others get to work on time.
Don't get me wrong, public transportation is indeed the Life-blood of NYC. But it used to be a lot better, years ago. Service cuts and mismanagement have really taken their toll. Been my experience that folks use public transportation because they need to, not because they want to. Who would honestly want to sit in a subway car that hasn't been cleaned, stinks of urine, has a homeless guy who's camped out at one end, a guy singing at the top of his lungs at the other end, and (if you're lucky) getting an announcement over the P.A. system that sounds as clear as Charlie Brown's teacher.... Who's the masochist that's HardCore enough to enjoy
that?!