The scratching is the result of the priority for retention over everything else.
I guess you either need the speedholster enough that the scratching is something you can live with (if you care about it at all), or you don't need the speedholster enough and a different holster/pouch will able you to keep the flashlight looking new-in-box.
There is no such thing as "HAII"
That's like saying "hard anodised soft".
SureFire state that their "HA" is Hard Anodised to Mil-A-8625 Type III Class 2.
Mil Spec Type II is sulphuric acid anodising which is usually dyed. It provides the very basic in corrosion resistance, abrasion resistance, and dielectric properties.
Mil Spec Type III is sulphuric/oxalic acid anodising which produces a thick and dense growth (aka "hardcoat"). This "Hard Anodising" provides excellent abrasion resistance and corrosion protection, but is often difficult to colour.
There is also no need to write "HAIII". It is a tautology. The 'III' is superfluous.