Don't feel bad. I have sourced flat tops for lights that require button tops before. Can happen to anyone.
Time for a discharge/charge test if you've not done so already. You should do this as part of matching batteries in a multibattery lion light. It's also part of conditioning and breaking in new batteries. You want the internal resistance, voltages under load, and CAPACITY to be as close as you can get it.
What device would you [or anyone else] recommend for the task of testing these cells? I'm as much concerned about the physical damage as any issues with the chemistry...I'm not sure if testing them on an Opus or [that yellow tester that costs $100 and I can't remember the name of] will give me a good enough gauge of their safety...or, will they?
I know I'm getting nearly to the territory of needing to start a new thread...though, this is in a funny way an extension of the original topic "What I've Learned..." and in a meta way is amusing to watch. Thus, continuing thread.
Also, though I don't currently (and haven't for the past few days had a chance to reply back to all of the other comments, but I shall simply say that all ya'll are pretty awesome, and even the earlier "harsh welcome" was...for me in the context of this post...quite welcoming. Like, I caught the ire and later sincere attention of one of this site's higher level contributors, and that's pretty cool for a welcome back to the world of internet forums. Reminds me of how some of the threads on MCB (mcarterbrown.com, a paintball forum I used to be very involved in) played out. Anyway...beyond the above battery stuff, I'm wondering what I can do to contribute positive information to the forum from this point...both dry snarky entertainment and quality thoughts on lights. I have a decent collection at this point, but the reason I bought most of them was because I saw a good review on them here...so doing light reviews on my own might be a bit of a redundant waste...so....eh....I'll figure it out. I'm just eager to take part in this place, while recognizing I'm still quite the newb just getting his first SolarForce and without a 6P...thus a lot to learn
Anyway...yeah...dented batteries...that happened...because my TM16 is too much fun to play with and I was putting in new cells with the excitement of a 7 year old on Christmas....also, I'm glad I don't drive a VW.