Take it to a hardware store...plumbing department. Then you can actually try different sizes, and only buy what you need, assuming they have something that fits properly.
If you work somewhere that has a maintenance shop, ask someone where the o-rings are. Usually they'll be in a stack of metal drawers with dividers. We have a huge selection in one of our maintenance shops, and I've gotten o-rings for lights and projects there a few times(though I'll still buy o-rings labeled for specific lights online rather than go out of my way to visit our other plant and dig through a seemingly infinite supply of o-rings that aren't always in the appropriately labeled bins).
Good luck.