Charging 14500 (AA) and 10440 (AAA) - One Charger?

wilrader

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Oct 16, 2009
Messages
1
Hey!

Is there a charger which can charge both 14500's and 10440's? Not at the same time, mind you, but preferably without having to use spacers or clips or anything?

I'm quite unfamiliar with LiIon's, save for what I've spent a good amount of time reading about, but I've yet to find a charger which can charge both. Any recommendations on not only the charger, but the brand for the LiIon's?

Thanks,
Wil
 
Welcome to CPF wilrader! :thumbsup:

There are a number of chargers out there that "claim" to be adequate for charging both 10440 and 14500 cells. Most of these use an improper algorithm for charging Li-Ion cells, and really shouldn't be used at all. Of the remaining few, some charge at a good rate for 14500's but too high a rate for 10440's. In most cases, this just shortens cell cycle life, and at rate of more than 1C, considerably with these tiny cells. Keep in mind also, that the "claimed" mAh printed on the side of the cell, in most cases is BS. I don't think there are any 10440 cells that are even 300mAh, let alone 500mAh. Most are around 250mAh, regardless of what's printed on the side.

For my 14500 cells I compromised on what seems to be a good charger for them, and while maybe having close to the maximum charge rate for a 10440, is probably OK. While this charger appears not to use an ideal algorithm, it's pretty close and should be reasonably safe to use on both size cells. I do use mine (I got from DX) for 14250 and sometimes 16340 cells as well. It's really too slow for 17xxx and 18xxx cells, but would work. I will admit though, that for my 10440's I mostly use one of three nano 10440 chargers that I bought, that actually works. The nano is a bit slow (about 90mA) but I figure it's easier on the cells. When it comes to 10440's there really aren't many choices as far as chargers.

I haven't used this charger much for charging NiMH cells, but it does in fact seem to work for them as well, albeit once again, a bit slow. It truly does seem to be a universal charger in this respect.

It is a one cell charger, but at the price point, you could always buy two or whatever. Again so far, I am pleased with my unit. It is built surprisingly well for a cheap charger and as I have pointed out elsewhere, the PCB lacks the cold solder joints and general messy appearance of most Chinese chargers in this category.

Dave
 

That is a possibility for a charger. Considering UltraFire's reputation however, and the fact that the HG-103W9V has been checked out to have a better algorithm, is more versatile and you can get two for less than the WF-138.....:thinking: That said, I do have a WF-138 RCR123 3.0-3.6 Volt charger that I use for LiFe RCR2's and LiFe RCR123's (3.0 Volt) as well as occasionally for LiCo RCR123's (3.6 Volt) and it does work. Presumably, both WF-138's have the same charge rate, 250mA/channel. That would work, but I've never been able to find any specs for the 10440/14500 version.

One thing I'll mention about the Soshine chargers at Lighthound, none of them will charge a single 10440 at less than 500mA (SC-S1 Mix and SC-S8) and the SC-S1 Min charges a single cell @ 700mA, both of which are way to high a rate. So, you would have to always charge three cells at a time with the SC-S1 Min or two cells at a time with the SC-S1 Mix or SC-S8. Also, I can't say I've heard many good things about Soshine chargers. There are some reviews on the Forum.

Dave
 
Top