LOL and willing to risk another post here to tell you how much that made me laugh.
OK, maybe I could contribute something since I have modded my Q3 extensively as well, but I don't wish to compete for most helpful here.
You will definitely see a big gain in output by upgrading the LED and the LED will even use a little less power because of the lower Vf. As far as which LED to choose, that depends a little on what you are after, since they tend to give different looking beams. I was drawn to the Seoul because I intend to have a Millermods Arc AAA Cree for flood and I wanted my second EDC to fill the other end of the ol' needs spectrum. So, the Cree will put out almost as much light with more in the spill. Most people find the spill very usefull and the throw to be about the same as the Lux III they retired. The Q3 has a reflector that works very well with either of these LEDs, though it doesn't maximize throw of the Seoul. I haven't seen much on the Edisons, and there are many more places I am aware of to purchase premium bin Seoul P4s or P4 bin Crees, so I would choose them for that alone.
Other things to consider when selecting the LED include:
-the need to prevent a metal reflector from shorting the Cree LED electrodes on top and frying the converter board,
-needing to clip the corners of a Cree emitter (if you choose not to use a star - mounting the LED directly to a big heat sink will keep it cooler),
-preventing the Seoul emitter from making electrical contact with the heat sink (again, not for stars),
-the more vulnerable lens on the Seoul LEDs.
I was worried about the gummy lenses, but I managed not to ruin mine. And another advantage to these mods is the potential for much longer runtimes if you have a low setting via converter board or two stage switch. I also recommend against running these lower Vf LEDs in direct drive with a 3.7V RCR123, and IIRC the stock Q3 board does just that on these higher voltage batteries. It would drive a P4 something like 50% over the upper limit given by Seoul for example.