Toughest & Most Reliable AA and 2AA

gnlw

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 12, 2008
Messages
46
What are the toughest and most reliable AA and 2AA lights right now? I've decided to buy lights for some friends and relatives as Christmas gifts this year. They are all in either law enforcement or work for the government in some capacity.

The 2AA light is going to be given to a government worker who is an electronics technician. He will use it daily to assist in working on both small and large electrical systems both indoors and outdoors, in both good weather and bad. It's going to get a ton of use and will likely be dropped on occasion. It needs to have a good low mode for indoors work, as well as a good high mode for illuminating things outdoors at a distance. I don't know what light he uses now.

The AA lights will be given to a couple of people in law enforcement. I'd like to give them a light that they can just put in their pocket for off-duty use. I would think the lights would get a pretty good amount of usage for doing stuff around the house, and maybe as a backup for their duty light. I would think the lights would also be subjected to somewhat rough usage. I'd like to give them a light that has both good low and high modes. I don't know what lights they use on-duty now, although I know they used to use the Surefire G2 a few years ago. My guess would be that they are using the LED version of the G2 on-duty now.

I need to keep the price for each light under $75. I'd like each light to have a good low mode and high mode. They need to be tough and reliable, and not need much maintenance. It doesn't matter if it's a clicky, or twisty, or tactical. It just needs to always work. Also, the lights will likely be run only on Alkaline batteries.

So far, I'm considering the Fenix, Nitecore, and Quark brands. Thanks in advice for any replies.
 
You can never go wrong with nitecore. I bought the NDI for my father who works on offshore oil platforms. Before he was using a mini mag but I told him it was embarrasing so I got him it. He loves it and its a big wow facter for all the guys at work. By the looks of it the light takes a real beatin, buts its still kicken.
 
Last edited:
1-AA, Fenix L1T-V2. Bomb proof mode switching, and personally I have dropped it more times than I care to remember. I have dropped mine hard/high enough to dent the bezel. The glass did not crack and it didn't degrade the water tight seal. My daughter submersed it to about 3 feet wading in the pool, but I told her to keep it twisted to HIGH and not rotate the bezel.

2-AA, Fenix TK20. I don't own one personally, but got a chance to play around with one and demo it at a CPF meet. Its a very well made light and solid construction throughout. It can take a fair amount of abuse as seen in this thread.
http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=219738
 
Last edited:
to gnlw --


Here's my suggestion . . . .


First, find out which flashlight(s) they are currently using.


-- What do they like about it.

-- What don't they like about it.


Then, factor those issues into yer' final decision.


Going into this blind can be a "hit-or-miss" gamble.


Just my humble opinion.

:candle:
_
 
The TK-20 is probably the toughest AA powered light I can remember but, unfortunately lacks a low setting.
 
If we're talking about reliability and nothing else the Arc AA or an Infinity is a contender if you can find one.
 
All the lights mentioned would be good choices and you cant go wrong with a Nitecore, Fenix, or Quark. Unless you are set on a AA, you might consider looking at the upcoming 4Sevens AAA (maybe the Ti version:). As a backup light, its size will make it more likely that it will be carried. I currently use a Fenix LD01 as a backup and on high it is almost as bright as the Surefire G2L.
 
To be literal the two strongest AA flashlights every made is the original Mini Mag. Which was to simple to break:whistle:, and the old Electrolumens 2x AA Lux III, who's body was machined from solid ¼ inch aluminum:faint:. These might be the strongest, but are no were near the best all round:shrug:.
 
Fenix L1T,LD10,LD20 and anything Matt has at batteryjunction. Any light can break sometimes, yes of course some more easily than others just pick a good light your interested in from a dealer like Matt who will take care of you if you have any problems. Good luck

http://www.batteryjunction.com/
 
To be literal the two strongest AA flashlights every made is the original Mini Mag. Which was to simple to break:whistle:


The switch was EXTREMELY easy to break. A light is only good as it's weakest point and that switch was WEAK. Not to mention incans aren't reliable. Inova now has a 2AA model the X2, it hasn't been battle tested, but Inovas are known for their toughness.
 
The TK-20 is probably the toughest AA powered light I can remember but, unfortunately lacks a low setting.

Well, the TK20 does have two (2) settings, one isnt really low as in less than a lumen or even 10 lumens.

TK20 Features
·Cree Neutral White (Q2) 7090 XR-E LED with lifespan of 50,000 hours
·Two modes of output, selected by turning the bezel (Patented):
-Turbo Mode: Constant 150 Lumens 2 hours (Ni-MH)
-General Mode: Constant 45 Lumens 11 hours (Ni-MH)

you can see some nice beamshots of the TK20 in action here on both modes.
 
Yep get the AA, Fenix TK20. Solid as heck and will always work.Great tint to kinda like an incandescent.
 
The less moving parts to go wrong the more durable. A twisty should be more durable than a button switch all things equal.
 
I haven't had many others; but can say that my Nitecore AAEZ went through the washing machine, has accumulated some dents; but still works fine.
 
Very simple.

1AA: Nitecore Defender Infinity
2AA: Fenix TK20

Both are suitable for law enforcement use and I'd trust my life to these two torches. The TK20 does not have a real low mode, but it is low enough to use while working on electrical wiring in a dark room (I have done this personally) and it lasts for about 10 hours on a set of NiMH cells (runtimes on alkalines are about 1/3 of what they are on NiMH's). They also both are brighter than a Surefire G2L on their highest modes.
 
Last edited:
Top