Flying Turtle said:
I don't feel I have made much compromise in quality or wasted my money in buying such lights as the Arc AAA and AA, UKeLED 4AA, CMG Infinity and Sonic, Eternalight Derringer, Inova X1, Fenix Civictor, E0, E1, and L0PSE, River Rock 2AAA and Headlamp, Task Force 1W 1AA, Energizer Folding Lanterns and Accent Lights, etc. All were less than $40...
Exactly right Flying Turtle. IMHO, some of the lights you list are world class - and all for less than $40. By world class I mean that a light is the best, or at least among the best, light in its particular specialized niche.
Arc AAA - best keychain light
UK eLED 4AA - best industrial, hazardous environment light
CMG Infinity - best pocket survival light
etc.
Some of these lights may have been surpassed by later models, but they were the best a few years ago.
Flying Turtle said:
Also, with the fairly rapid recent advancements in lights it would be kind of depressing to see that $200 light shown up by a $50 one a few months down the road. And that does seem to be happening...
I have the feeling that buying a U2, quality issues aside, is equivalent to buying the latest and greatest home PC for $5000. Right after you get it, everyone is amazed by its performance. But, two years later its performance will be matched by $2000 PCs. And two years after that it will be beaten by cheap bargain PCs.
Flying Turtle said:
It's just a hobby. If you get more pleasure from having a few of the best that's great. For me, I guess the bottom lines are "bang for the buck" and diversity. Like I've said before, it's a whole different story if you really need bulletproof, powerful lights for life or job. I can certainly appreciate them, but like probably most of us here, I just don't need them.
I'd go further than that regarding "bang for the buck."
I view lights primarily as tools. If a light works as intended, and keeps working after being banged around and dropped, then I couldn't care less about the glossy finish and how cool it looks.
In a situation where life depends on lights working, I'd much prefer to have two or three "decent quality" lights than one "highest quality" light.