Newbie Help - P3DCE, SF G2 or TerraLux MiniStar5 Extreme

I'm looking to purchase a new flashlight and have narrowed it down to the following three (budget is a factor here – don't want to spend a fortune)

Fenix P3DCE
Surefire G2 (not the LED Version)
Mag 3D + TerraLux TLE-6EX-B MiniStar5 Extreme drop in.

Despite a lot of searching I'm finding it hard to find information on which of these three will give me greatest distance. Primary use will be out walking the dogs – I live in a rural area – so once out of the village it's dark – and my main aim is to see the dogs and what's ahead rather than where I'm walking. I have a Princeton Tec Impact that is fine for close up with great battery life, but is no good for distance.

I will get rechargeable cells for which ever route I go – CR123 or D Cells.

I already have the Mag 3D – dug out of a box in the garage – so no expenditure required on that bit.

Any help or advice or even links to other posts (which I have obviously missed) much appreciated. If there is a flashlight in these price ranges that I have missed that will outperform the above please let me know.


Thanks in advance.

For your purpose, my vote is the Terralux drop-in.

My vote is for a light that is not on your list, the WF-600(review) with 2 18650 3.7v rechargeable batteries and charger(total ~$45).

It will throw further then you Maglite, G2, and P3D-CE/Rebel 100. It is larger then the G2 and P3D but smaller then the Maglite 3D. The Maglite 3D will project more then the P3D and G2 but the WF-600 beats the 3D Mag in throw and output.

Or you could get a Malkoffdevices Drop-in for your Mag 3D. More expensive but also pretty bright and built to last.

:welcome:

Thanks willrx and gunner12 for the info.

Had thought about the Malkoff - but they seem to be all sold out - even though a new batch has just been released. They must be good. Price wise - whilst 75 USD, at current UK exchange rates, this is the same cost as for a SF G2 from a high street store!

Will check out the WF-600 - not familiar with that one.

I have the Terralux TLE-6EXB in a 3 D cell Maglite. For the money it offers a great bang for the buck and good run time. I recommend that you start with that, it will always be a good flashlight to have around, you can always upgrade to a more expensive light. Good luck whatever you choose.

The WF-600 looks impressive from the spec on DX. Costs seem to be relative. The WF-600 at current exchange rates is very cheap - if i convert the cost of a TLE-6EXB here in the UK from GBP to USD it's costing me USD52, whereas the total cost for WF-600 with 2 cells, charger and express delivery is USD59 - circa GBP30.

brightangelpoint said:

The WF-600 looks impressive from the spec on DX. Costs seem to be relative. The WF-600 at current exchange rates is very cheap - if i convert the cost of a TLE-6EXB here in the UK from GBP to USD it's costing me USD52, whereas the total cost for WF-600 with 2 cells, charger and express delivery is USD59 - circa GBP30.

Click to expand...

I didn't consider your exchange rate situation. It sounds like you're all set with 18650 batteries then?

As a "walking the dog" light, your 3D Mag with the drop-in seems to be the best fit out of those lights you mentioned.

Thanks for all comments and help. WF-600, cells and charger now ordered.

brightangelpoint said:

Thanks for all comments and help. WF-600, cells and charger now ordered.

Click to expand...

Good luck with your new light! Come on back and post your impressions. It will be good to hear how you like it.