Layman's Opinion - Lumintop Tool Copper XPG2 AAA

run4jc

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 27, 2009
Messages
3,794
Location
Sweet Home Alabama


Note – this light was supplied by Lumintop as part of their global testing campaign. I realize that there have already been reviews of this light - most notably Selfbuilt's review of the aluminum version and mhanlen's review of this copper version. I don't mean to step on their excellent reviews - only supply a "man on the street" layman's review.


AAA lights have really improved in the past few years. How many of us have carried the old standby Fenix E01? Or perhaps one of the more modern lights – one of the new Surefire Titans – or maybe a Streamlight, Olight, etc., etc. No doubt the field is crowded. On Amazon a search for "AAA Flashlights" brings up 15 brands, with multiple variants among each brand.

Narrow your search to a AAA light with a clicky switch and the field really begins to narrow. Arguably, the Fenix LD02 is the most well-known of the AAA clicky lights – and of course many are familiar with the Streamlight Microstream.

Regardless, it remains a crowded field so when Lumintop introduced their aluminum "Tool" AAA clicky light I barely noticed. But then this tested light, the Copper Tool XPG2 was released and it was different enough to get me to notice. Granted, there are other copper AAA lights out there with the Maratac being one of he most well-known, this Lumintop is one of the few (if perhaps the only) with a clicky switch.

My sample arrived in a nice presentation box and included a simple instruction sheet, extra o-rings, a lanyard, key chain and a snap on clip. The light was vacuum-sealed in a foil pouch – obviously to keep the copper finish from tarnishing. No battery was supplied, and Lumintop specifies a AAA battery and recommends against using a 10440 battery. I am using an Eneloop Pro in my sample.





I don't normally like copper flashlight simply because of the weight, but in this small AAA light the weight actually seems to be a benefit. I removed the clip and dropped the light in my pocket and the weight seems to keep the light reassuringly deep in the pocket.

It fits well in my large hands, and the clicky switch is easy to activate.


The light clicks "on" at medium, then cycles to low, then high. There is no mode memory. After clicking the light on, you can lightly press the button to cycle through the modes or you can repeatedly click off and on. There is no momentary press activation.

Tint from the Cree XP-G2 R5 emitter is fairly neutral with a slight hint of green.


Lumintop offers this light with a Nichia 219. I would really like to see that light as it would surely have a much more pleasing and natural tint.

Lumintop rates output at 110/32/5 lumen. My readings are 92/20/2 – not enough difference to quibble about.

Here are a few random iPhone photos of the light on low, medium then high. This building is about 50 feet and there is a lot of ambient light (sorry). High is useful – medium and low not so much at this distance.




This fence is about 20 feet away.





The Big Green Egg is about 10 feet away





Here is a photo comparing the relative size of the Lumintop to a number of other small lights. From right to left: Zebralight SC32w (123 size battery), the Lumintop, Surefire Titan A, Surefire Titan Plus, Fenix LD02, Fenix E99 Ti (the last 5 use AAA batteries) and the Nitecore Tube (rechargeable)



My opinion/verdict? This is a nice little light that I've enjoyed carrying and using for the past week or so. It feels good in hand and produces a nice range of levels from the ubiquitous AAA battery. While it is no bargain at the average price of around $60, it is competitive with other copper AAA lights.

What would I change?

-Mode memory would be awesome – coupled with a true "moonlight" low. While we all want our lights to have a powerful high setting, a truly low setting is very valuable for navigating a dark space without upsetting night adjusted vision or disturbing a spouse/family member/friend. I personally would like to know that the light is going to come on at the lowest setting – whether that is via mode memory or rearranging the sequence. Opinions vary – tactical users probably prefer that it come on at the highest setting.

-A more substantial clip. This is a beefy light, and it's fairly easy to remove the clip. Maybe too easy.

-Support for the 10440 battery. We all know that copper is a very effective heat conductor – it might be fun to see how bright this light would be with 3.7 volts going through the LED. I may try it….they "don't recommend" using the battery but they don't come right out and say that the light will be damaged. The LED can certainly handle it but the driver might not be able to.

Overall, I like it. It fills a niche - a AAA clicky light made out of copper.
 
Last edited:

ven

Flashaholic
Joined
Oct 17, 2013
Messages
22,533
Location
Manchester UK
Nice run down and pics, you have some nice mini /key chain lights there, thanks for sharing!:thumbsup:
 

Thetasigma

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 10, 2015
Messages
1,197
Location
Michigan, USA
Nice review, thanks for sharing.

The Nichia model is indeed a very pleasing neutral tint, with wonderful color rendition, particularly the subtle reds of my skin that are washed out in a Cool white light and make me look like a cadaver.
Being this is a light I clip to my shirt pocket for EDC, I personally feel that the addition of mode-memory would be detrimental to this light.
 

jon_slider

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 31, 2015
Messages
5,155
-Mode memory would be awesome – coupled with a true "moonlight" low…. I personally would like to know that the light is going to come on at the lowest setting

Thanks for the post.
I like that these lights are now using NO PWM.

I prefer that the light comes on in Medium mode first, as I use medium more frequently than Low.

FWIW, there is still availability of the ReyLight Special group buy Copper Tool with N219, which does use LMH sequence, and the low is supposed to be 1 lumen.

The Nichia model is indeed a very pleasing neutral tint, with wonderful color rendition, particularly the subtle reds of my skin that are washed out in a Cool white light and make me look like a cadaver.
Well said! I agree completely, XPG2 is brighter, but lacks CRI.
 
Last edited:

N_N_R

Enlightened
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
446
Location
Bulgaria
I'm really considering one, but given I have the old, aluminium Tool, I wonder if this is a justifiable purchase... lol.
 

jon_slider

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 31, 2015
Messages
5,155
I wonder if this is a justifiable purchase... lol.

Yes it is, for at least 3 reasons,
1. the new models do not have PWM and
2. offer the Nichia High CRI. Besides,
3. Copper is antibacterial.. google Oligodynamic :)
 

jon_slider

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 31, 2015
Messages
5,155
Copper… underrepresented
Lumintop helped me remedy that :)
black ano is intentionally underrepresented in my accumulation

IMG_0409.JPG


IMG_0509.JPG
 

N_N_R

Enlightened
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
446
Location
Bulgaria
I sent the guys an e-mail to ask if it's available and if so, order one. Jeez. My budget hates me.
 

jon_slider

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 31, 2015
Messages
5,155
I sent the guys an e-mail to ask if it's available and if so, order one. Jeez. My budget hates me.

Im enjoying watching you spend money.. LOL!

Not sure if youre ordering an XPG2 version or if you want Nichia LED

I favor the Nichia, and this guy: 395090663 (at) qq.com was selling Copper ReyLight Tools for $39. I dont know if he still has any.

there are 4 versions of the Tool
1. Aluminum with XPG2, mode sequence MLH
2. Copper with XPG2, mode sequence MLH
3. Copper with Nichia and modes MLH
4. Copper with Nichia and modes LMH (the ReyLight version Im giving you the email for above)

and btw, now that Im talking about Copper Lights, the Maratac AAA Copper with XPG2 is currently available for $43 here

Hang on to your wallet :)

Oh, and heres a picture of the ReyLight head (patina by MiracleGrow) on one of my Maratac bodies (the Tool and Maratac will both work with each others heads):
IMG_0700.JPG


you can see here both Lego swaps work (and the difference in tint for XPG2 to N219):
IMG_0444.JPG
 
Last edited:

N_N_R

Enlightened
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
446
Location
Bulgaria
LOL.

Well, the only one offered by our local dealer is the Lumintop XPG2 version, med-low-high. Just like the regular aluminium Tool which I already have. I didn't want to order from abroad as more expensive packages usually get stuck in customs and I have to pay additionally. Moreover, with the current exhange rate EUR/USD ... ordering from abroad isn't cheaper for me either. So yeah, I'll take some bad pics tomorrow when it arrives :D

Cool pics, btw :D
 

RGRAY

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
1,176
Consider a ToolVN you won't be disappointed.
 

Aldiggi

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Feb 26, 2007
Messages
191
Location
NYC
These lights look really sweet. Might just have to pick up one for my old man and I.
 
Top