[ QUOTE ]
StainlessSteel said:
I have been doing a lot of reading about the pros and cons of led and incan.
Everyone seems to agree on one thing: Incan lights will out throw leds.
My question is this:
Will leds ever be better than incan in ALL respects?
Example: Will a 2x123 led light one day be "brighter" and "better" than a P61 bulb on top of 2x123?
Will it have more light, more throw, and longer battery life?
Thanks guys,
SS
[/ QUOTE ]
For what it's worth, I think the P61 on a 2x123 setup is a mistake, despite it's performance. When you are draining a 123 cell in 20 minutes, you have to be pulling around 2 amps. If you read the post by silverfox on testing 123s at various currents, you will notice that he has stopped testing 123's at 2 amps current rate because the heat generated made him nervous. I am sure there are others who are very happy with this setup, but IMHO,I think a 3x123 would be more appropriate for 120 Lumen use - regardless of LED or Incan.
- Durability - LED no question
- Full spectral output - Incan for a long time, but LED will eventually match at this power level
- Efficiency - LED is a match if not better already, and continuing to improve.
- Throw - I have seem some pretty strong throwing LED based lights. I think this is a matter of optimizing optics for LED instead of incan.
- 120 Lumens of real output from the front end - This requires at least a W bin Lux V (still not so widely available), and with optics losses, an X bin (which is virtually vapor ware to the average user).
I have seen presentations at conferences for a 1,000 Lumen Luxeon prototype, which some have speculated is intended for the 12 volt auto market. I suppose when these come out we can dim one down to 120 Lumens for you. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif