Agreed. If you are to only own one then the 170T might make more sense in allowing a very low 0.08 lumen to a high 171 lumen. Very versatile light on it's own. Much as I find the high CRI lovely I still feel that it should be used paired with the 170T or any other more powerful lights. There are times when I find the wider beam profile and lower lumen output of the high CRI a little lacking, but if you don't really need a light to shine out there and touch someone, the high CRI does serve you very well.As much as I see the utility of the High CRI as a photographer (I do dabble a bit on my own, and not as much at night, though I'm sure I'd dedicate myself to night shooting were I to own the High CRI), seeing the three lights hit the 30m palm grove sold me on the 170T. On the lower settings, moonlight and above, the 170T doesn't need to have such a glaring hotspot, and can be useful in a wide range of situations, but is still able to reach out and touch something where the High CRI cannot.
I can't afford both. I wish I could, and I'm selling off gear every day, but I'm running a pretty bare-bones operation here, and if I can only have one HDS light, I feel that my money is best spent on the utility I would get from the 170T. I love the colour rendition, I love the soft tones and distinguishable browns of the High CRI, but on those opportunities where I would ABSOLUTELY NEED the brightest thing on two wheels, I can't say no to the extra lumens of the 170T. It would still be useful as an EDC light on lower settings, while giving you the ability to light up someone's world should you ever need to.
Thank you for the beautiful shots, though. It just seems that they sold me in the other direction than most that have posted or will post.
Keep up the great work! An excellent review of the best lights on the market, from what I've read.
Brad
Yes, I know about the Sundrop and had wanted to purchase one initially but the low lumen ratings of the Sundrop and the fact that it really is a full flood flashlight had me looking at the HDS high CRI instead. I had intended for this light to be used on my frequent overnight stay in this remote island and the HDS clicky still offers a little bit more throw than the Sundrop from what I have seen in the video footage.That is a fantastic write up and some great pictures :thumbsup:
It is interesting to see the difference with the 140GT. The high CRI does a very nice job.
BTW - if you like your CRI HDS, you would love a McGizmo Sundrop :twothumbs
That's what I meant. In my years of being alive, I have not met anyone who possesses a mixed feeling about durians. Either love it, or hate it. And I love it! :nana:Ahhh. Durians. You either love them or hate them. And I hate them. The flavor and texture is awesome but I can never get over the smell.
Good thing you guys didn't get hit in the head by one of those things. That's how people literally get killed standing under those trees.
I think these two photos shows the difference really well why a warm light doesn't mean high cri. The high cri pic seems to have more depth and color range than the warm pic, even though the color temp and shade of the pics are almost identical.
And these two pics show that color range really really well. Notice how the green of the leaves are almost identical shades but the reds and browns are shown in their natural color rather than being washed out with blue. That's what high cri does for you right there.
Trust me, you won't regret it.What a spectacular thread!
Thank you and ever thanks...
And just made me order a High CRI...
My biggest pleasure to be of help to this community. :wave:Fantastic thread and pics Andy!
Thanks so much for lugging the Nikon D3 out on your trek with you and taking these pics!
What a spectacular thread!
Thank you and ever thanks...
And just made me order a High CRI...
Unfortunately, I don't earn commission from Henry. :ironic:Like you, I ordered a high CRI clicky after seeing this thread (and selling a couple of lights in the Marketplace). The pictures are really what pushed me over the edge after wondering about UC glass vs Sapphire and primaries vs rechargables.
I wonder how many others finally pulled the trigger because of this thread? Henry should be pleased!