None of these lights look like they're meant to be throwers. If you want to state that "As advertised, the XP-G has a rather larger apparent die size and slightly higher surface brightness, along with wider emission angle" then feel free to. But accusing XP-G flashlight manufacturers of being treacherous and misleading in its throw is like buying my Geo Metro from me and being mad that it won't tow your boat.
If you want to check the throw of a light, look at lux and beamshots. If you're determined to buy lights before anyone else, know the general characteristics of the things in question. As posted above, expecting monster throw from a non-aspheric optic in a P60-sized lamp is unwise - especially when you know that it's built around the XP-G. Like the geo, it's meant for efficiency rather than laserlike output. One could argue that since lights are made for the LEDs (just ask Cree, they know the money's in fixed lighting), that work needs to be done on the flashlights, not the LED.
*The Geo Metro I have is a 1.0L 3 cylinder 5-speed.