18650 Question/Confusion. Help a new guy out!!

Troop#26

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Dec 19, 2006
Messages
127
Hey guys, sorry Im still a little new here so Im just trying to sort out all of this flash-a-holic jargon. You guys have been a great help so far! I have decided (finally) on two lights to carry on my duty rig. Both are Pila lamps, they came very highly recommended and seem to be a good quality and cost effective option. The concept was to get two torches running on the same kinds of cells for their various purposes yet creating redundancy so only one kind of cell need be carried and confusion under stress is eliminated. They are as follows:

Pila GL2 "Cavaliere"

This will run either the Pila 3W LED Emitter or the Lumens Factory HO-4 (3.7V)

It will be running a stock Pila "Clickey" Tactical Switch and will be run on rechargeables ie some 18650.

Pila GL4 "Imperatore"

This will be running a Lumens Factory HO-9L (9V) in the front and a Pila RED Led Tail Lamp Module in the Back. Occasionally this may be run with a Lumen's Factory EO-9L (9V) think heat. Also ALWAYS running on rechargeable thus 18650.

Now as stated above I want to run both of these lights on rechargeable cells all the time thus 123's are never going to get in these lights. The obvious choice right of the bat was Pila batteries, cause well they are Pila lights. However after some reading online regarding cells I have discovered two things. Firstly the Pila 600P the batteries that power both of these lights are really just 18650's thus no different from these normal Lith-Ion cells we can buy elsewhere (correct me if Im wrong). Secondly these batteries (the Pila's) seem to be very very expensive when compared to other 18650 cells I have found online (thats if they are the same thing).

This leads me to this simple question: Would I be better off going to Pila 600P's or other cells?

Additionaly, I have come across some confusion regarding the cells themself. It is my understanding that the Pila, and the majority of other 18650's out there are "protected", which in my very juvenile understanding means if they get to hot they shut off to stop from exploding. Exploding flashlight in your hand=bad!! However I have now come across these:

http://www.batteryjunction.com/li18322mahre.html

they seem to indicate there is some kind of PCB protection integrated with the cell thus maintaining a constant voltage or Im on the really strong pot of coffee? Im not really sure what that means and smoke is currently poring out of me ears and the few remaining brain cells I have left are struggling to comprehend this info. Thus the simple question here is, am I better off buying a normal 2200mAh cell with this protection circuit PCB thing as above, a Pila 600P 2200 mAh cell or something of an 18650 2600mAh that has no protection like this one:

http://www.batteryjunction.com/li18cyce326h.html

and then adding some kind of protection like this

http://www.batteryjunction.com/prcimopfor3l.html

Where is the best place to buy same batteries? I just happened to find Battery Junction, but some one had mentioned to me that there are people with in the CPF community whom might have some other resources or sell them their selves. Care to share?

Lastly, we have come to chargers. I would assume then that the Pila charger would charge all other forms of 18650 cells... it seems like a strong candidate as it has a Quick charge a Slow charge and a standby mode, trickle charge. It is also my understanding that each "well" is independent so as you can charge one cell at a time regardless of where it is at in the charge cycle etc. Is this a good choice for a charger or are there other (read less expensive) options out there that offer similar charging options ie quick then slow then trickle with the same independent wells? Also I need a 12v vehicle cord for same charger. Lastly is anyone aware of a charger that has 4 independent wells as I would love to be able to have 3 batteries charging at any given time for my lights?

Thanks so much for all your knowledge and resources!!

Yours truly

Stephen
END POST #2:rock:
 
pila battereis are protected.

most "on battery" protection does not include thermal protection and if it did its position on the cell would make it less effective for that. although there IS mechanical protection on all good us aproved cells that can include last hope thermal protection, but ummm, it isnt.

there is A pila charger that you would not at all want to use with any type of non-protected cell. it was designed strictally for the pila protected cell.

standard li-ion chargers of all sorts work basically the same way, get one that is within the capacity ratings for the cell your purchacing, or it will take longer to charge, which is no big deal.

adding in the protection just like that :) except its not as easy as it looks, you have to run a Opposite pole to the opposite side, one misteak in insulative properties of that wire (or flat metal band) and you could cause a complete short.
so the consideration of the connection and insulation used to run that connection to the PCB is high. then how far that sticks out changes the diameter of the battery.

i find its easier to buy them done.

4 channel li-ion chargers are not as cheap at all. but 4 cheap ones is :)
any finished 18650 charger is a good deal, and they potentially will work with protected and unrpotected as they voltage terminate or voltage control for charging. (with current limitations)

ok i hope i said that all right, cause i dont have a pila. i thought pila battereis were a little high priced for what they are, but i wouldnt want a "cheap" cell either, with a pila battery and a pila light you could insure total support from pila , that is one concideration.
 
Last edited:
Troop#26;

You need to have a good understanding of lithium ion battery operation.

If you take the time to understand the technology, then you can use any of the #18650 cells.

I have used hundreds of standard #18650 cells without a single problem. I would not short one or overcharge one. I do like to use only quality brand #18650 cells.

Educate yourself and then use the cells you decide on.

Larry Cobb
 
Welcome to CPF Troop#26!

I buy protected 18650 cells from CPF member AW. I have no complaints, and have not heard of any.

I will not run unprotected Li-ion cells due to my forgetful nature. I'd rather play it safe.
 
Last edited:
The default mainstream choices for a large protected cell and charger boil down to three: AW's 18650, Pila's 600P, and Wolf Eyes' 168A. All are now 2200 mAh. AW's cells and charger cost the least, and the new charger (by Ultrafire) is truly smart. Also, you can buy a DC adapter for the charger to use it (or a second such charger) in your car or truck. And finally, AW's cells are a bit less fat, making them more likely to fit in so-called 18650 bodies for which Pila and Wolf Eyes cells may be a shade too fat.

Pila has the smartest charger of all and its cells deliver the highest voltage under load. But you will pay somewhat more for the cells (about $24 each) and a lot more for the charger (more than $40). Also, it's not clear that you can charge other brands of cell in this charger. It's pretty much a closed system, designed as a system for those willing to pay a premium to get the best.

Wolf Eyes cells arguably (though not definitively) still deliver the finest protection; they are priced in-between AW and Pila. But Wolf Eyes has fallen behind in charger technology; their fast charger is not "smart": It does not "know" the cell's voltage as it charges it, relying instead on the cell's protection circuit to trip. In theory, this practice could shorten the cell's life span.

I use Wolf Eyes exclusively, because that's how I started and I prefer to standardize. I have two of their AC chargers, 2 of their DC chargers, five 168A cells, and five 150A cells. All my bodies are Wolf Eyes, and the cells are the perfect length. But if you're starting fresh, I would go with AW. The prices are so nice, you can buy extra cells and chargers without thinking twice. Lighhound, a CPF dealer, sells the cells and charger domestically if you're willing to spend a bit more to avoid international shipping.
 
Last edited:
Top