TrevorG
Newly Enlightened
I have a TIVO series 1 and a Replay 5040. I have had zero problems with the TIVO but I can't say the same about my Replay or the Replay that I bought my parents for Xmas. The TIVO is reliable and has better software, the Replay 5000 series (prior to TIVO 2) had better features such as USB, Ethernet, File sharing and progressive output. I will not purchase another Replay. Although the TIVO 2 has all of the connectivity that I was looking for, I will wait for an HDTV capable model before I buy another one.