Beamsoht Xr-19 Vs PD-S?

[ianb]

I've tried searching for a direct comparison, but couldn't find any :shrug:

I'd like to see this if anyone has both?

thanks, Ian

 

[Fringe]

I like them both, but hands down, if I had to choose, I would NEVER give up my XR-19. I think this beam profile rules.

 

[charlesn]

+1 to Fringe's comments, and I own both lights.

While the Seoul has a marginally brighter hotspot and a wider overall beam, the Cree's spill outside the hotspot is much brighter compared to the Seoul. So, oddly enough, while Cree's beam is a bit narrower than the Seoul's, it does a significantly better job of illuminating a wider area.

My only complaint about the Cree is the tint, and the Seoul is the clear winner in that dept. Not sure if Cree tint has gotten better since Don acquired the Crees he used in the XR-19 PDs.

 

[jch79]

But you gotta love the smaller form factor of the PD-S.. which is exactly why my XR-19 went away! :shrug:

Stupid opinions - why can't we all just get along! :nana:

john

 

[Codeman]

Unless you're looking for whitewall shots, check out my Ti-PD/PD-S/PD-S-Mizer Shootout.

For the money, my particular PD-S has a slight edge in total output, throw, and tint, while the XR19-C has a slight edge in spill. The differences are so small that, from a purely functional standpoint, it's a draw. But the LED lottery still lives, so if I had a different PD-S and/or a different XR-19C, it might tip the other way.

To me, the primary difference between the two is whether someone has a preference for the piston or a clicky. In real use, that's the only difference that can be easily detected, IMO.

For me, I tend to hold them like I used to hold a cigarette. Because of that, I lean towards the C-pak. The narrower body is easier to keep a good grip with when held between my first and second fingers with my thumb on the switch. I find it more likely that I will drop the PD-S in this grip. So the XR19-C is used around the house more. But...

Which light do I carry in my pocket? The PD-S. Go figure....

So even though I've had both for a couple of months, I still haven't really formed a preference. :touche:

 

[ianb]

Thanks for the opinions guys :thumbsup:, I have to agree with Fringe and charlesn I LOVE my XR, but haven't tried the PD with a Seoul yet, I'm sure in time I'll get one, but for now will just window shop

I like the handsome look of the longer head on the XR but like the compactness of the PD.

I'm usually only have one light for each niche(EDC/i.e pocket, car, bedside, Lamp/HID etc) so can't really use the 'buy both' mantra here, but I guess I will get a Seoul in time for evaluation purposes and see who wins :naughty:

thanks, Ian

P.S. Codeman, I'm just going to look at those beamshots...

*EDIT - Codeman those are perfect :kewlpics: thanks *

 

[Codeman]

:thumbsup: