carrot's guide to high-end lights

carrot

Flashaholic
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
9,251
Location
New York City
http://www.gearcarrot.com/guides/lights/

I am looking for questions, comments, criticisms and possibly even information.

I am writing a guide to help answer many questions a flashlight newbie may have as well as provide a suitable reference guide for more advanced users who may have a lapse in memory and forget somethinig important. I would consider the main content to be more than 2/3 finished with polish and photos notwitstanding.

Right now this is the result of two nights' work and should this receive positive feedback I will continue to work on it until it is a polished guide that is worth money (but of course I won't charge).

Old site: http://cpf.carrot.googlepages.com/flashlight_guide
 
Last edited:
Very nicely done. I can see a lot of though went into your writing. Clear and conscise.:thumbsup:
 
Nice job bro!! Great reference tool for any flashaholic old and new :thumbsup:
 
Put those Maglites away!

In flashlight enthusiast communities, Maglites are considered the de-facto standard for flashlights you shouldn't be using. There are a few exceptions -- modded Maglites, some of which can get bright enough to cook eggs and start fires (we'll talk about that later too), the MagLED line of flashlights, and the MagCharger. Your ordinary Mini-Maglite uses an incandescent bulb that needs to be replaced every few hours and is a decent light for roughly $10 but is hardly the tip of the iceberg and should not be mistaken for a high-end light. They are quite high-quality in build but the technology they use has been eclipsed many times over and are not worth using if you are serious or interested in getting serious with flashlights. The MagLED lights are pretty good values and are decent lights even amongst the flashlight community but Maglite has been getting flack for picking up the Luxeon LED technology once it has already gotten stale and surpassed in efficiency and brightness.

I only got as far as the fifth segment and realized it was just personal opinion, rather than authoritative. There are many flashlight enthusiasts that have a higher regard for Maglite, than you indicate as "basic knowledge" for "the flashlight newbie".

I've been with CPF for nearly seven years. I started out with somewhere between 30 to 50 flashlights, with probably a dozen of them being Maglites. I appreciated them then, just as I appreciated other flashlights. At present, I have several hundred flashlights, and an appreciation for the many varied brands and types. I still appreciate Maglites.

Actually, the post that brought one of my earliest responses on CPF was in response to a "trashing" post of a particular brand. The brand isn't even one of my favorites, but it was a flashlight. I happen to like flashlights, and couldn't understand why anyone wanted to dislike some particular brand of flashlight.

Flashlights are an industry. Flashlights are a product. Only a limited number of those producing this product produce with a view that flashlights are a "hobby". There is certainly nothing wrong with flashlights as a "hobby", but to focus only on "hobby" interest, is what gives life to the trash-certain-brands type activity. Flashlights, even on CPF, are no more just "hobby", than cars, guns, knives, stamps, coins, or any of the other everyday products that can be made into an enthusiast's hobby.

Many CPF visitors, lurkers, and members don't come here to participate in a hobby. They come for information or have a healthy interest in what's available, the pros, cons, and information about what's new in flashlights. CPF, as it has done for every aspect of flashlights, embraces those that don't seek the hobby aspect, the same as it embraces those that seek the hobby.

I guess I just see nothing "cool" about telling the ones you call "flashlight newbie" that some of their own treasures aren't "cool".
 
Last edited:
thank you 4 somewhere to start i can see it is a matter of opinion but it helps
 
I like it. But you gotta start listing off some actual high end lights. Fenix L1D? Photon? Dude! When you say high end on CPF, you better bring it :) .
 
Two suggestions - not criticism, just ideas. . .

To be negative. . . the Maglite section strays close to opinion stated as fact, even if you did ballance it with praise for the magLED.
Can I suggest that you just stick in "In my opinion. . ." or even "according to the majority of flashlight community members. . ." or some other weasel words.

Apologies for being so picky - It's an old journalist hang-up of mine.

Point two - a request: what I'd like explained (and I keep intending to post, requesting this), is flashlight math. I have read, but cannot find again, the formulas people use to calculate runtime from output. . . it draws x, so runtime must be in the order of y.

Finally, praise (I'm not the gushy type). I never knew what LSD (in relation to battery chemistry) stood for untill I read that. Ha! It has value, even though you will never please all the people all the time.
 
This might be an extremely minor thing, I just thought noobs might be overwhelmed by the amount of info. I'm not saying that there should be less info, on the contrary, the more the better. Perhaps it can be solved by creating a table of contents for the logical "mini chapters". A noob might have a specific question in their mind and want to jump straight to the section.

But again, it might be just me who's lazy reading so much info at one go :p
 
That is off-topic and nonsense. bessiebennie's thread is about budget lights. This thread is about high-end lights.

What are budget light to most of us here might be very high end for many other people.

Some people have a budget of $20 while others have a budget of $2000.

Argument aside, besiebennies thread should be included for those who don't have as big a budget or people who want to test the waters.

The Welcome Mat could also be a good thing to link to, along with the Maglite Upgrades thread for those who want to do something with their Maglites.

Great post Carrot,
 
This might be an extremely minor thing, I just thought noobs might be overwhelmed by the amount of info. I'm not saying that there should be less info, on the contrary, the more the better. Perhaps it can be solved by creating a table of contents for the logical "mini chapters". A noob might have a specific question in their mind and want to jump straight to the section.

But again, it might be just me who's lazy reading so much info at one go :p
I just read the entire thing and its very well written and clear! :thumbsup: Very good work and it must have taken ages to write and construct it.:bow:

I agree with kurni though that it may be better to split things up a little as it is a pretty large read and may be a little too much on the one page for some. But its all there and nothing needs to be re-done.

Most importantly you forgot to put a link through to CPF where you mentioned it! LOL. :ohgeez:

Great work!
 
Nice work Carrot! I think that maybe you could expand a little on the Li-On section and provide a little more warning/info on their use. I don't know how much depth you want to get into but using Li-Ons can be confusing and dangerous to newbie flashaholics.

Also I remember reading a thread where a poster wanted to make it clear that there was no such thing as "Type III hard anodizing". He wrote that it was either "Type III anodizing" or "Hard anodizing". I personally did not know this but I thought I woud bring it up.

Overall awesome work, keep it up!
 
Last edited:
Top