Re: Got bit by the lith bug! Best entry level 2x1
I've been into lights for about two months now. In that two months, I've acquired 2 E2e's, an L4, a few modded KL1's, an A2, an E1e, Surefire M3 (don't have this in my hands yet), 2 PM6's, a Brinkman LX, a Scorpion and a G2. I've also invested in a handful Pila rechargeables and a charger.
Of course the Brinkman was the least expensive. I EDC my E1e with a modded KL1 (not cheap). But when it comes to incandescent lights, the two that get the most use are the Scorpion and the G2 and for two simple facts. They were both cheap and they are both very bright and relatively compact. The are also tough and I don't worry much about dinging them.
The Scorpion has it's pros and cons.
What I like about it is:
1. It is bright.
2. The rubber cover makes is easy to hold on to.
3. E series LED bezels fit on it.
4. Comes with a momentary and constant on clickie.
5. Easily made rechargeable with the use of a Pila 168S battery and a Stinger 3.7v bulb.
What I don't like about it is:
1. The rubber is subject to tearing.
2. The rubber makes it hard to get in and out of your pocket.
3. The head's coating is wearing off.
What I like about the G2 is:
1. It is relatively small and bright.
2. It is fixed focus that is appropriate for most situations.
3. It is not made of metal and is very tough. I've dropped mine a bunch of times and it is no worse for the wear.
4. Can be made rechargeable with the use of a Pila 3.7v 80 lumen lamp and 168S battery.
5. You can use a KL3 (very mod friendly) on it.
What I don't like:
1. It's kind of ugly compared to the other Surefires.
2. It feels a little bulky.
3. Although it will operate with P61 LA, you have to worry about the lens melting (in extended use).
I think both lights are great, but if I had to choose one, it would probably be the Surefire because it's easier to pocket and it gives better light as a rechargeable.
You'd probably be happy with either one. I'd lean toward the G2 though. It's tough and since it will be your only 123 light for the time being, it's good to have something that you wouldn't have to baby. Later when you move up to a 6P or something similar, the lamps and stuff will interchange.
