Kaidomain Maglite Q5 Drop-In !!!!

[kosPap]

the chinese are amazing!!!
Kaidomain Maglite Q5 Drop-In

 

[AvidHiker]

Hmmm, looks strangely familiar. I seem to recall something similar with a patent pending.

Gene's design still looks better to me.

 

[glenda17]

He guaranteed us it $29.95 would include the lens, bezel and Q5 dropin. Now its 29.95+19.95+bezel. You can buy a Deerelight thrower for what this setup costs.

 

[stitch_paradox]

the chinese are amazing!!!
Kaidomain Maglite Q5 Drop-In

Not quite. What a ripoff. This is a perfect example of what I'm talking about. :sick2: But it's just my opinion. I think the original still has the best design.

 

[alfreddajero]

Hmmmmm, but taking a look at the spot why does it seem so squarish.......

 

[Stereodude]

Hmmmmm, but taking a look at the spot why does it seem so squarish.......

Aspherical lens. The die is a square, so the hotspot will be a square.

 

[Stereodude]

Hmmm, looks strangely familiar. I seem to recall something similar with a patent pending.

Gene's design still looks better to me.

They both have a heatsink, a LED, plug into a mag socket, so it would make sense there are similarities between them.

 

[alfreddajero]

Okay thanks for that bit of info.......didnt know that at all.

 

[Marduke]

What's supposed to keep it in place? No lip on the top of the slug, the light post is spring loaded, and there is nothing keeping it from sliding around and smacking the bottom of the reflector.


Also, anyone else notice the LED on on a very thin post, not exactly well heatsinked. Most of the space under the LED is air, not aluminum.


Also, if you look closely, it's not made out of a single piece of milled aluminum round stock. It's at least 3 different cylinders press fitted together. Any hopes of that magically staying together with some moderate bumping around?

 

[stitch_paradox]

Quite an eye there Marduke. Might be held in place by glue.

 

[mudman cj]

There is another problem with press fit cylinders. Heat will be very poorly conducted through those gaps. No gaps you say? On the microscopic level there are peaks and valleys on both surfaces, and usually it's just peaks against peaks. Air is a terrible conductor of heat.

 

[TORCH_BOY]

I feel safer buying a complete light

 

[qip]

price seems reasonable for what it is, your getting a big heatsink an led and a driver...just fill in any gaps with arctic silver or alumina and your set

 

[Boostedvl]

In the specifications section their description of "Illuminate objects at a distance of 600+ feet and will light a 2 inch red reflector at a distance of more than 1/4 mile" seems familiar to me.

 

[clg0159]

What's supposed to keep it in place? No lip on the top of the slug, the light post is spring loaded, and there is nothing keeping it from sliding around and smacking the bottom of the reflector.


Also, anyone else notice the LED on on a very thin post, not exactly well heatsinked. Most of the space under the LED is air, not aluminum.


Also, if you look closely, it's not made out of a single piece of milled aluminum round stock. It's at least 3 different cylinders press fitted together. Any hopes of that magically staying together with some moderate bumping around?

This is exactly what I was thinking! That Q5 is practically levitating on that post.

 

[AvidHiker]

They both have a heatsink, a LED, plug into a mag socket, so it would make sense there are similarities between them.

Thank you for that, but I think you missed the point of my comment (and you appear to be trying to insult me, which I think is sad... but if it makes you feel better about yourself, by all means... slap away).


The basic design is similar, of course, and it lacks Gene's wedging construction, which would be a blatant ripoff. However, suggesting removal of the cam portion of the stock reflector seemed, to me, to be a pretty unique requirement. One that I only became aware of after discovering Gene's dropin (the first of its kind as far as I know), but perhaps I overreacted. Ok, there are other reflectors that can be used instead, I see that now - I'm by no means an expert on mag dropins, just making an observation.

I certainly don't appreciate your rude post - how about we just have a nice civil conversation, maybe you can make a little more effort to have a point instead of stating the obvious. I'm perfectly happy to adjust my opinion should someone offer me a good reason, but I'm afraid your post added absolutely nothing to the thread and only served label you a "troll" in my eyes.:thumbsdow

 

[kavvika]

I know of no single properly-heatsinked (single) LED upgrade that utilizes the stock reflector and doesn't require the cam to be removed, whether it be Gene's or custom. Elektrolumens's modules use a separate attached reflector, otherwise they would require the same to be done.

As for the product itself, it seems like an inexpensive alternative to Gene's module, but I'll wait until the reviews to pass judgement. Would you rather a Terralux module that will overheat just like a stock MagLED, or this, for the same price?

I'm curious as to what driver this uses. I won't be purchasing one since first, I prefer to use "C" Maglites, and second, I'm building my own module using a H22A heatsink and a Photonfanatic Seoul P4 USV0H emitter for around the same price, and construction will undoubtedly be better since I can provide my own QC.

 

[AvidHiker]

In the specifications section their description of "Illuminate objects at a distance of 600+ feet and will light a 2 inch red reflector at a distance of more than 1/4 mile" seems familiar to me.

Quite right! Thank you, I completely missed that.

Sad to see this kind of thing happening on such a regular basis these days.

 

[AvidHiker]

I know of no single properly-heatsinked (single) LED upgrade that utilizes the stock reflector and doesn't require the cam to be removed, whether it be Gene's or custom. Elektrolumens's modules use a separate attached reflector, otherwise they would require the same to be done.

Yes, I believe I just came to that realization in my previous post (and you did have to qualify that with "properly heatsinked"). Still, I've never seen the idea discussed anywhere else but on Gene's site (granted, its probably buried in an old thread or two somewhere as well), just my observation but I think its clear where some of the text came from for this product description.

As for the product itself, it seems like an inexpensive alternative to Gene's module, but I'll wait until the reviews to pass judgement. Would you rather a Terralux module that will overheat just like a stock MagLED, or this, for the same price?

Ok, rhetorical questions now. Actually, I'd prefer to see some originality instead of cut and paste. Personally (note - I'm not suggesting that you should feel this way) I'm not interested in cheap ripoffs of other products, it just rubs me the wrong way.:shrug:

 

[kavvika]

Gotcha. I didn't notice that KD copied part of Gene's product description until after my first post.

But what do you mean by originality? I really only know of one way to LED-ify a Mag, and that's a o-sink with the LED perched on top inside the reflector. And what about all those cheap Cree P60 module ripoffs on the same site? IIRC, BOG was the first company to release a LED upgrade module, then the Cree-volution hit and DX and KD became flooded with them. It wasn't until the middle of last year that Gene produced his P60 module. Not criticizing, but going by what you say, would Gene's module be a rip-off of, say, DX #1343?

EDIT: I re-read your post, and it's possible you meant originality for the product description and not the product itself. If that's the case, then forgive my misunderstanding.