I seem to remember a link a few weeks back regarding Osram LED's
Some amazing beam shots. I don't know what optics or any particulars but in general they can generate up to about 1000 lumens with one LED. You just need to have 18 volts to run it properly.
Given you can get optics for an Ostar, but not for a tri-rebel (the idea of trying to design an optic for that is a complete nightmare), why would the latter be better?
65lm/W at 350mA (which is where you get just under 100lm/W with a Rebel). You'll actually get even better than that with the Ostar if you drop the input current to 175mA which is the same power input as a tri-rebel. Anyway lumens are no good if you can't focus them, which is the problem with the tri-rebel. You can make a useful light with decent throw and compact size with the Ostar - with a tri-rebel you can't.