Thanks for the reply's.
I bought one yesterday, sign said on sale but it was 19.99 not 13.99 like I saw months ago. So I found out the led bulb doesn't work in other 4AA lights. The light is bigger, clunkier and chunkier than it looks in the package. But IMHO not too heavy. Though definitely not EDC. More like a winter coat pocket carry. The 4 leds are much brighter than a pt attitude and with a 3 cell xpr103 or 4 cell kpr113 it is quite bright. With these bulbs the beam isn't smooth at close range. But the optic seems to give it more throw.
And except for size it is kinda a poormans A2. In another thread someone mentioned they like the A2 because they only have one light in their hand and can quickly go from flood to spot. That is the case with this light when you replace the center led with a regular bulb. When longer runtime and less spot is needed you can put the original led bulb back in, as the package claims 130 hours runtime.
The center led bulb is brighter than a impact II. Mine has a blue and purple ring. I want to test this light outdoors, and I can see why most people kept theirs. One of those things that grow on you. Just in case I made sure I got a gift receipt with it (to make a return easier).