Being generally distrustful of Big Business I won't say this is impossible, but I'd like to see some kind of proof of this if you have any.
That's a pretty serious allegation you're making there...
That said, I'll agree that a Surefire is probably overkill for most people - but then probably 80% of what CPF'ers own is too.
Everyone who isn't blinded by the gun hobby knows that gun rags writers are paid major dollars to write flawless review on guns. Most magazines, not just gun rags, are quite cheap because it is the adverting that pay their salary; they only charge use for shipping. That is why it generally only cost a dollar or 2 for most magazine out there. The more magazines they sell, the more money they can charge the companies advertising with them. On top of that, companies pay them a lot of money for favorable reviews. Actually, all gun reviews in gun rags are favorable. Last but not least, whenever a custom gun maker is mentioned as a friend or a friend of a friend and he happens to be a great custom maker that specialized in certain firearms, we can rest assure that this friend or friend of a friend pays handsomely to have his unique skill published to the audiences that will most likely buy if they have the mean. When it comes to high end hobbies, which guns and flashlights fall under, advertisement and product endorsement is the backbone of the business. I am surprise you weren't aware of such dealing.
Again, Surefire is a great manufacture but I don't think their products are worth the money for what I do. However, if I am a SAR professional, I will go with them as well as one or two other top dollar brands for flashlight needs. The reason is rather simple as these tools would be the cheapest but most profitable investment for that line of work. To put it into perspective, I'd be looking at spending less than $1000 for 3 or 4 lights from two or three top dollars makers and these lights would have no bs warranty unlike Fenix and 4Seven, which requires me to keep a receipt and be the original purchaser from 4Seven. I would use these lights and if they do break, I would get a new one, possibly a upgraded version, free of charge. For the people who depend on their lights for living, this is a very cheap option. For 99% of the people in the world as well as those on CPF, it is a luxury we can opt out of. For me, Maglites serve me just fine and also come with lifetime warranty, which I never had to utilize.
I personally would not buy a Fenix and definitely not through 4Seven until they modify their warranty policy. If I buy from 4Seven, they should have my name and address to charge me money and to send me the product. Why in the world would I need to keep a receipt years and years later, assuming their products last that long? In addition, if their products are so great, why would the warranty applies only to the original purchaser. That is the same thing as saying that all lights should be bought new. If they don't want to deal with too much legacy cost, aka cost of having to warranty a product years after selling it, they should have a 5, 10, or 15 years warranty, which goes by the serial number of the product and not worry about who bought it where and when. This is why I prefer Craftsmen products from Sears; if something goes wrong I take it back and get a new one. I have many tools from Sears and have not utilize the warranty yet. Sears knows that they have to make/re-badge tough products or they would go bankrupted with high legacy cost.