I haven't used my Mahi much since I got it, as nice as it is, I'm particularly prone to the Haiku.
The Mahi has a nice beam and works well with most LEDs I've tried but for my tastes it needs something punchy in it like the Osram to warrant the extra bulk.
Got myself some Cree XP-P in 5000K which are reasonably comparable to the Osram at the drive currents I'm running (using a 3S ~650mA on high).
I'm a fan of nice tints and high CRI but can make exception for this set up. Low CRI, tint isn't bad but the throw is great.
I measured about 1/3 more throw using a 119V 3S in the Mahi compared to Haiku (from memory, a while ago). A quick and dodgey test shows I'm getting about 5x Haiku 119V and about 4x Haiku XPG2 throw using the Mahi XPP.
Haven't tried the XPP in a Haiku, don't intend to.
After a bit more play I'll set up a test as best as I can and get some figures in cd for the Haiku and Mahi for reference.
I'm happy with what I'm seeing so far.
Edit:
Did some more (pretty dodgey) measurements and I got 3.9x more lux out of the Mahi/XPP vs Haiku/XPG2.
All pretty arbitrary, and using the same (XPP) LED in both heads would give a better reference point, but interesting none the less. I wasn't happy with the figures I was getting as they were at odds with what I last remember recording (lux figures of the Haiku similar to Don's) so I'm not including them.
Obviously given the same LED, then the difference would not be so great (I remember getting about an extra third lux comparing the 119V in Haiku vs Mahi as I mentioned.
Whatever the case, it's not surprising that you'll get much greater throw by choosing one of Don's Osram LEs regardless.
My not so scientific test was done using a phone app light meter at a distance of 1m and 5m.