[ QUOTE ]
js said:
raggie33, and any others who are interested,
The Catholic Church does not (as an official policy) prohibit organ donation, but they may have an official policy against cremation. The problem of organ donation from a Catholic point of view (or I should say "from this Catholic's" point of view) is that most organs, to be useful, must be taken from a donor who is still alive. Alive and "brain-dead", I think the term is. There are exceptions: corneas can be taken from truly dead people, I think. But a kidney or liver or heart must be taken from a person whose heart is still pumping and whose lungs are still breathing.
The issue (for a Catholic) is this: we believe that we are only stewards of our bodies, of our minds, of our talents, --in short, God has given us everything. Catholics believe, for example, that suicide is wrong precisely because it is not up to us to decide when and how we are to leave this world. Thus, the problem with organ donation is that the person is "killed" from the donation. The person is still alive at the time of donation. I could elaborate on this, but this much is enough to point out where things get complicated for a Catholic. Please keep in mind that I do not mean to offend anyone, or start an argument, only to answer raggie33's question and add to the discussion.
Thus, the real issue over organ donation and cremation, (again, from the Catholic point of view) is that the Church teaches that on the Day of Judgement the souls of the deceased will be reunited with their bodies. We will be using our bodies again. Now, God, being Almighty can bring the matter back together regardless of what state it is in or where it has ended up. I don't think that this should be thought of as a gathering together of every single original atom, as from that point of view our bodies are continually being created anew. Yet, even so, in some mysterious way, the material, i.e. the body, IS important, and will be resurrected. That is why "good biomass" is taking up useful space in graveyards around the world. We reverence and care for the bodies of the deceased because they were, are, and will be, important and valuable. Catholics refrain from cremation because it is against the spirit of the Catholic teachings. If God says (through the Church) "you will need this again" it is not wise to burn it to ashes, in my humble opinion.
As for those who are of the opinion that it doesn't matter one way or another, and think that showing such regard for the body is silly, think of it this way: people often revere and cherish "keepsakes" from friends and relatives who have died. They are doing honor to the memory of the loved one in this way. In a similar, but much greater way, we are honoring the deceased in showing respect for the body. From a certain point of view it may be silly, I suppose, but think how you would feel if, just after your mother died in her hospital bed, someone hauled off and slapped her in the face. You would be shocked and outraged (I hope). It would be an offense against your mother. It is for this very reason that we are NOT allowed to treat a corpse as just another hunk of inanimate matter. From a purely "scientific" point of view, this may be a social prejudice, but from any human point of view it is more than a prejudice. The body must be respected after death, and everyone understands what is signified by laying flowers on someone's grave (or spitting on it.) "Soylent Green" only has the force that it does because of this truth.
PLEASE NOTE: I do not mean to criticise anyone's choice to be cremated or to be an organ donor! I only meant to point out some of the things that come to this Catholics mind when thinking about burial, cremation, and organ donation.
So, I voted for burial, no embalming, but burial and embalming would be acceptable.
[/ QUOTE ]
Jim, I had a couple pages of text typed, in response to this, however I decided not to post it. I believe that anything I'd have to say in response to this would be taken the wrong way and start a religious flame-war. The only reason I'm responding now is to make you aware that I did read your posting and respect your views and opinions.