Assuming you want to stick to non-customs and LEDs:
Wolf Eyes SuperStorm is probably the brightest, with 7 R2s and around 1450 emitter lumens. The smaller 3xXR-E Q5 EagleTac M2XC4 is also brighter than most quad-dies, at around 800 lumens.
Best throwing is Saabluster's DEFT (but that's a semi-custom). Best with a reflector and single die LED is the Tiablo A10. I'm not sure about furthest throwing quad-die LED with a reflector... probably JETBeam M1X or Neofab Legion II.
However, since you have very few posts, I'd like to quickly point out something: a 2D Maglite starts at around 40 lumens and after 5 minutes runs at 20 lumens for the rated runtime. If that's what you're used to, the XR-E + 2xCR123A standard 200-250 lumens would blow you away.
On the flip side, if you know you need lumens or throw, LEDs still can't top incan hotwires or HIDs in either area. Your namesake is a prime example of that, but for runtime you can consider hooking up 3 larger li-ion cells to a WA1185 for around 1000 OTF lumens and decent runtime (50m with 3xC, 35 with 3x18650). Or if you don't mind startup times consider HIDs for the best efficiency while over 1000 lumens.