djpark
Enlightened
[ QUOTE ]
The Action Light is a flashlight in every sense - Webster: "a small battery-operated portable electric light."
Henry.
[/ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Gransee said:
But if you guys think I should change our claim I will. Instead of, "first single cell, regulated LED flashlight" I could change it to something like, "first single cell, regulated, handheld, LED flashlight", etc. I am fine either way.
[/ QUOTE ]
A lot of people seem to argue by heart feeling. But if we look at the point brought out carefully, we see that the challenge HDS put is not the fact if ARC's claim is correct or not, but rather to the definition of the "flashlight" Peter is having and it is very clearly answered to the point.
To me, the case is closed.
-- dj
The Action Light is a flashlight in every sense - Webster: "a small battery-operated portable electric light."
Henry.
[/ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Gransee said:
But if you guys think I should change our claim I will. Instead of, "first single cell, regulated LED flashlight" I could change it to something like, "first single cell, regulated, handheld, LED flashlight", etc. I am fine either way.
[/ QUOTE ]
A lot of people seem to argue by heart feeling. But if we look at the point brought out carefully, we see that the challenge HDS put is not the fact if ARC's claim is correct or not, but rather to the definition of the "flashlight" Peter is having and it is very clearly answered to the point.
To me, the case is closed.
-- dj