Yes, I agree fully with you that in general you don't need more than 100 lumens for any EDC task. (Though, this does also depend on the individual and what their "EDC tasks" really are.
For example, if you are a LEO who carries a firearm while you are off-duty (like me), the HDS "tactical" flashlight that is categorized as such for a LEO to carry on duty or off on HDS' website, still has a max output of only 250-325ish lumens, yes it is nice that it turns on at max output because that's what you would want in that type of scenario, however 300 lumens is still not good enough for a light in that role (not in modern times at least). Back in the day (15-20 years ago or so) guys used to get away with 50-200 lumen range. But today that's unnecessary, why give yourself that disadvantage? Other companies are more appealing for this role at least, such as malkoff and modlite.
For example modlite offers a small 18350 handheld option, with around 1300 lumens and 54k CD. After studying some charts/tests done, the light sustains roughly 1,050 lumens for the entire first 5 minutes the light is on, then drops down to roughly 700 lumens for the following 2 minutes and then finally at about the 7/8 minute mark finds its place at about 435(ish) lumens for the remainder of the cells life. With that said, usually a "tactical" type of encounter off duty specifically will generally be finished well within that 5 minute mark. So instead of 250 we just 4x's the amount of light we have to work with.
With that said, for years I've wanted an HDS, contemplated grabbing one just for an EDC role/task but I really cant see myself carrying (2) lights, 1 dedicated EDC and 1 dedicated "tactical". Just too much space and heft and I know I'd end up just leaving the HDS at home.
Granted I've pulled out the modlite countless times for general EDC tasks including changing my vehicles tire, and REALLY wished I had another light with me with a lower mode. Hence why I came back to see if HDS finally bumped up their numbers at all. Unfortunately they didn't. So I guess my dream of owning one will need to continue to be put in the back burner! -- With that said, I think the HDS (especially with the rotary option would be an amazing choice for purely an EDC light without the gun-fighting aspect thrown in the mix).
Anyway, take care and thanks for chiming in!...
Love talking lights and the philosophy behind their use!