I'm a mod at a car site where the report button is used 99% of the time to report spam. Yup, good ole SPAM. Folks join up, create a thread that looks legit and "bam"……a link to free term papers, letters from Santa, low interest loans etc.
Every so often one pops up there where it's a Hatfields vs McCoys deal and more times than not it gets squashed without much issue. I've hit the report button here from time to time my own self. But not before advising said person "knock it off fella or I'll report ya". Or there was the times I got PM's with links offering me free stuff or my favorite "single Russian girls" lol.
There was an incident recently in another section that was quickly getting out of hand worse than those covid threads. That one needed to be squashed in my view. I personally didn't see anybody attacking anybody with the report button. What I saw was "guys, this fire is getting hot fast" and somebody pulled the fire alarm. It won't me, but it wasn't a surprise that somebody did.
So if I had a vote I'd say keep the report button.
Ps there are 24 members logged in currently. 200+ guests.