So, we bought an iPad the week it came out, and I've actually used one, so I feel it is now time for me to comment again. That and my craziness at work has let up somewhat.
OK. Multi-tasking. To say that the iPhone and iPad "don't multitask" is flat out wrong. The hardware is fully capable of multi-tasking, and does it all the time. You can listen to music while surfing the web. If that's not multi-tasking, what is it?
That said, the thing that people are getting at when they say this is that you can't run two or more third-party apps at the same time. This is a software/OS limitation, however, and can be lifted any time. And in point of fact, iPhone OS 4.0 will enable third party multitasking on the iPad, iPhone 3GS, and 3rd gen iPod Touch. It comes out this summer.
Flash. Flash is a pig, both in terms of memory and processor use, and it's an adobe product. It should be replaced, and it will be replaced, and Apple is just forcing the issue. If this is a deal breaker for you, so be it. Personally, I am with Apple on this one. Anything that I have needed so far, flash-wise, has been taken care of by an app. Need to watch a youtube video? There's a youtube app that works great. Need to watch a TV show? There's a free "ABC Viewer" app that also works great. Ditto Netflix, and Hulu will be (or maybe even already has) come out with an iPad app.
I have yet to run across any webpage where I noticed any problem by not having flash. Now, granted, I'm not a big web-surfer, so maybe my experience is unusual, but I don't think it's going to be far from what the average person will experience.
As for uploading photos to your iPad, you don't have to email them to yourself!!! That's totally ridiculous. Whoever said that must have no experience with the iPhone or iPod touch. These devices, including the iPad are meant to be synched with another computer.
THE IPAD IS NOT A NETBOOK. IT IS NOT A LAPTOP. AND IT IS NOT A LAPTOP REPLACEMENT.
If you wanted it to be those things, you are going to be disappointed and you won't buy one. And that's fine. It wasn't meant for you.
So what IS the iPad if its not a netbook or laptop replacement?
The iPad is a very intimate, and very capable mobile device. It will (or already does) shine in the following areas:
1. Games.
2. eBooks.
3. Web surfing and email.
4. Remote screen / terminal applications.
Before I take these one at a time, let me just give you my first impressions of the iPad. Well, actually, my VERY first impressions at the store were underwhelming. I was like, "eh. I'm not sure I'll get one." I mean, they were positive impressions. I was really impressed with the sound (more on this in a minute) and with the screen (wow is that thing beautiful), but I wasn't feeling the whole "magical" and "revolutionary" vibe, to say the least. But I went back a couple more times and read about some of the future apps for the iPad and talked with my wife, and we decided to get one (more for her than for me). And so let me talk about my "first" impressions over these past two or three weeks or whatever its been.
First, I don't know how they did it, but the sound on this thing is FANTASTIC versus what you might expect. It's way better than most, if not all, laptops. Crazy good sound considering it's a flat thin metal and glass object with only three small rectangular holes for the sound to come out of. But however they did it, the sound is VERY respectable. Quite good enough to be enjoyable. It won't replace your home theater system or anything and you won't host a dance with it, but it does the audio job and does it well.
Second, this thing is FAST FAST FAST. Talk about RESPONSIVE! Again, I don't know how they did it, but it is far faster and graphically capable than it has any right to be in my opinion, based on my previous experiences and expectations. It's freaking crazy. And you can see this in the games that are already out for it. This thing is going to RULE the mobile gaming device scene. Rule. And the games are CHEAP! An "expensive" iPad game is $15, and most are under $10. Crazy. And the iTunes storefront setup and SDK allows for lots of small-time programers to get into the market, vs. the PC game scene which is mostly dominated by the big game companies.
Third, the screen is gorgeous, vibrant, and with a really good viewing angle range. Two people can easily share a moive watching experience on the iPad. And, WOW, do HD movies look good on this thing. As do TV shows streamed over the net.
Fourth, the iPad is an intimate device. You curl up with it. You can use it very well lying down with your head propped up. Or curled up in a chair. It's always on. It's lying around. You grab it and go and are surfing the web or checking email in an instant. It's incredibly responsive. Apple made a choice to go with the iPhone OS over OS X. I expected them to go with OS X and to make a laptop replacement. But they went the iPhone OS / mobile device route. And I think they made the right call.
When I started just using this device, that's when I started to feel the "magical" vibe. And to think there was something to the notion that the iPad is "revolutionary". A little bit. I think it is. I think it will be. And I think that all those people predicting its failure are suffering from a failure of imagination.
If you think of the iPad as a terminal--as a window, a portal, into your powerful desktop or laptop computer, then so many possibilities open up. There's already a proof of concept app out that allows you to move windows from your main computer onto you iPad. The main computer on your home network is the one running the program (for example, Photoshop) and doing the heavy lifting, but the USER INTERACTION and input happen through the iPad. And the communication happens over the network, over the wi-fi.
Apple is the first company to really change an OS to use a TOUCH UI. Previously this was not the case. Previously you just had a stylus replace the cursor/mouse. But working with your fingers and hands is different than using a mouse or a pen. And the iPad is the fullest expression and utilization of that fact. It's just a different experience than a mouse-based UI. And until you've spent a few hours using it, you won't appreciate just how different it is, and you won't appreciate the potential of the touch UI. It's pretty amazing. My wife is a graphic designer, and one of the first apps we bought for the iPad was Sketchbook Pro. Cost a whopping $10 or so! And she immediately did a painting on the iPad, after only spending a couple minutes checking out the onscreen instructions. This thing is sensitive--there are a lot of touch sensors in it, and good extrapolation algorhythms.
The iPad IS going to be part of a mobile device revolution. It's going to be big. There are things to complain about. You can lament the lack of a camera or gripe about flash or third-party mutli-tasking, but this is missing the larger picture. Even if this device isn't for YOU, it is going to be right for a lot of people. Apple has a winner here. Just wait and see.