I think I'd have to go with....
Hmm, tougher choice than I imagined!
I didn't have it very long, but my Dad likes the heck out of the UK 2AAA Eled I bought from Brightguy for $9.88.
Although I would also give high marks to the Attitude.
And that Dorcy you mentioned only lacks water PROOFNESS to be a really great light! It is damn good as is!